Incapacitated subject
An incapacitated subject means a subject who, for reasons other than the age of legal competence to give informed consent, is incapable of giving informed consent according to the law of the Member State concerned (Art. 2(2)(19) EU Clinical Trials Regulation 536/2014). Typical situations are dementia, severe psychiatric illness, intensive care and emergency settings, and neurological conditions affecting decision-making capacity.
Art. 31 CTR allows clinical trials on incapacitated subjects only under cumulative conditions: informed consent is obtained from a legally designated representative; the subject receives information adapted to their capacity; the investigator respects the explicit wish of a subject capable of forming an opinion to refuse or withdraw; no incentives are given; the trial is essential for that population and cannot be conducted on capable adults; it relates directly to the subject's condition; and it is expected to produce a direct benefit outweighing the risks, or only minimal risk and burden. Art. 35 provides a derogation for emergency situations where consent may be obtained afterwards.
From a data protection perspective, the incapacitated subject remains the data subject. The information required by Art. 13 GDPR must be given to the representative and, where possible, to the subject in accessible form; rights are exercised through the representative; and the trial's DPIA should treat the population as vulnerable, with heightened attention to minimisation, confidentiality and the handling of capacity assessments, which are themselves health data.
